The couple worked through their issues, renewing their vows in 2017, and welcomed a second child, a son named Jace, in 2018. However, they faced other obstacles in their marriage. In 2019, the couple revealed in their then-joint podcast "Whine Down with Jana Kramer and Mike Caussin" that Caussin had a relapse in his sex addiction but did not cheat on Kramer with another woman in a physical way. That same year, Kramer revealed on their podcast that she had found inappropriate photos in her husband's phone.
Though they managed to work through their difficult times, it was too much for Kramer, and the couple split for good in April 2021. Caussin had allegedly cheated on Kramer with multiple women. Their divorce was finalized in July 2021, with the pair sharing custody of their two children.